Is This a Fox For The Twenty-First Century?

 Today's exercises occupy many niches that one can usually find in writing books, including sensory exploration, etudes, introspection, and simple brainstorms. It comes from a writer who prides himself on his wide experience in the field of creative writing and who offers a multitude of courses for the struggling writer, including "How To Write a Sentence" and "The Triangle Method to Character Creation". This is John Fox, and though his website makes clear he has a high opinion of himself, I believe for the purposes of this particular field that it may help. After all, what he is offering are steps that have seemingly worked for him and hoping that they will work for others. 

Fox begins this article somewhat long-windedly, explaining that he interested not in spurring full creative works like with writing prompts, but rather in helping to train the skill of writing. I do believe these two concepts are related, though, and I think he does as well. He thinks that these particular exercises will aid in the creation of a story structure, generate dialogue, or help work out of a creative rut; just what I'm looking for. He even handily has them divided into categories; senses, dialogue, objects, emotions, and characters (though he admits that the lattermost one is the one he put the most time into; the character prompts constitute roughly half of the list). 

The sense-based prompts provide almost all of what one needs to know about the strengths and weaknesses of this particular list. Here, in my mind, is one of the better ones: 

"Think of the most deafening sound you can imagine. Describe it in great detail, and have your character hear it for the first time at the start of a story."

See? That's a simple and effective prompt. It doesn't hold the writer's hand too much and it allows a lot of original thought to go into realizing the prompt into a piece of writing. I don't think you could give this to a room of people and not have them come up with many wildly different examples. In contrast, this one is far more, as a Dungeons and Dragons player would phrase it, "railroading": 

"Have a man cooking for a woman on a third date, and have her describe the aromas in such loving and extended detail that she realizes that she’s in love with him."

This one is flawed in my mind because it not only provides far too many details, but also an explicit endpoint. This is going to feel less like an exercise in your own creativity and working towards something that's already been set out for you. Now, maybe this would be helpful for some people, but I personally think this limitation is a dead end. He did mention at the start of his article that he wanted to have these exercises lead to the possibility of more involved or productive writing later on. 

This particular concern of mine manifests throughout many of the exercises in this particular list. The dialogue options fare a little better, mainly due to the prompts being far more open-ended. The prompts all have to deal with exploring the different ways in which dialogue can be utilized in a story, such as expressing context without stating it explicitly, showing the proximity of a relationship, or even the lack of dialogue expressing these concepts just as well. However, one prompt, in particular, is very underwhelming: 

"Write a scene composed mostly of dialogue with a child talking to a stranger. Your mission is to show the child as heartbreakingly cute. At the same time, avoid sentimentality."

There's a lot wrong here. The "mission" statement isn't terrible but the directions given are vague in the worst way. The prompt seems to be expressing too many experimental variables for its own good and I feel for most it would be an unhelpful way to try and induce proper writing flow. It feels to me like something that would be pulled out at a writer's workshop to try and have a "one size fits all" exercise, which I think is particularly unhelpful given how varied by nature writing is. 

Unfortunately, these weaker prompts show up more and more as the list goes on. The "objects" category is the worst about it, with basically all of the prompts having the problem of being far too specific. They basically all boil down to one concept; assign a backstory to an object that elicits emotion from the reader. This is not a bad concept in the slightest and is a good way to have a writer flex their ability to think on their feet. But for every one of these prompts to be based around this idea is overkill and results in many prompts too specific or narrow for their own good. 

The emotion prompts fare much better, with them largely being dependent on the author applying their personal experience to get the desired results, something which I think would be an effective brainstorming tool for a majority of the authors seeking this sort of information out. 

The character prompts are numerous and varied, but it should be said that they experience the same fluctuation in quality that the others have demonstrated. I do believe Fox when he says that he is most comfortable in character writing, not just because of the relative volume of the character prompts versus the other disciplines, but also because the prompts in this section do tend to be of higher quality than the others, even if there are still some in this section with the more dubious qualities of the other lists. That being said, a lot of these succeed where the others fail because they offer high-concept ideas but with open-ended scenarios. My problem with many of the others is that they were far too closed off and essentially was putting the reader on track to finish a pre-made idea. I can confidently say that the ideas in this last cluster of prompts are far more useful. 

While I may have been critical of much of this article's applicability, there are at the end of the day many more good prompts than bad, and even the bad prompts might only be a matter of opinion. These prompts are a good way to get the creative blood flowing for the writer stuck in writer's block. As we will see here, that is more than can be said for some of the lesser writing exercises to be found on the internet. 

The prompts reviewed can be found here: https://thejohnfox.com/2016/05/creative-writing-exercises/


Comments